Key Takeaways
  • Married women do live a little longer on average. In a 2020 meta-analysis of about 7.9 million people, unmarried women had a 22% higher risk of death than married women. For unmarried men the figure was 46%
  • The gap is smaller for women than for men in most big analyses, for single, divorced and widowed alike
  • Mothers lived slightly longer in a Swedish study of about 1.4 million people: at 60, mothers could expect 24.6 more years and childless women 23.1. Risk looks lowest at a moderate number of children, not the most
  • None of this proves cause. Healthier people may be more likely to marry and have children, and the researchers say so
  • Quality and connection matter. Better marriages are linked to better health, and across 148 studies, people with stronger social relationships of any kind had 50% higher odds of survival

Do women live longer if they're married with children, just married, or single? In 2019 a widely shared story said single, childless women were the healthiest and happiest group. Other headlines say the opposite.

Here's what the largest studies show for women specifically, and what seems to matter more than marital status or family size. None of this is a case for marrying or having children for your health: life choices aren't health interventions, and many people don't get to choose them anyway.

1.5 years
Extra remaining life expectancy at age 60 for Swedish mothers compared with childless women (24.6 vs 23.1 years), among people born 1911–1925. For men the gap was about 2 years (Journal of Epidemiology & Community Health, 2017)
Part one · Married or single

Married vs Unmarried Women: The Big Numbers

Evidence: Consistent association — observational only

The most direct answer for women comes from a 2020 meta-analysis in Global Health Research and Policy by Yafeng Wang, Mark Woodward and colleagues. They pooled 21 studies covering 7,881,040 people to ask whether the link between marital status and death differs for women and men. Every study was adjusted for at least age (Wang, Glob Health Res Policy 2020).

Compared with married women, unmarried women had a 22% higher risk of death from any cause over the study periods (relative risk 1.22). For men it was 46%. By group, never-married women had a 46% higher risk, divorced or separated women 27% and widowed women 14%. The women-to-men ratio of 0.87 was statistically significant: the gap is real for women, but smaller than for men. The authors concluded that being unmarried "conferred higher risk of stroke and all-cause mortality for men than women" (abstract via DOAJ).

Figure 1 · Wang et al., 2020

Higher risk of death compared with married people, by sex

Women Men Never married vs married +46% +67% Divorced or separated +27% +59% Widowed vs married +14% +30% Any unmarried all groups pooled +22% +46%

Bars show pooled relative risks of death from any cause (1.46 = 46% higher), each group compared with married people of the same sex. Observational studies adjusted for at least age.

Two other large reviews broadly agree:

A "22% higher risk" is relative: it means 22% more than the yearly chance of dying for a married woman of the same age. In midlife that baseline is small, so the absolute difference is small too; it grows with age. It is not 22% of your lifespan.

Part two · Divorce and widowhood

Divorce, Widowhood and the Sex Gap

Evidence: Consistent association — weaker in women
Figure 2 · Five meta-analyses

The risk linked to being unmarried is smaller in women

Comparison (vs married)StudiesWomenMen
Any unmarried status21 studies, 7.9 million people (2020)1.221.46
Divorced or separated104 studies, 24 countries (2012)1.221.37
Widowed123 publications (2012)1.151.27
Widowed15 cohorts, 2.3 million people (2011)1.04 not statistically significant1.23
Non-married, older adults53 comparisons, 250,000+ people (2007)Married 0.88 overall estimate "did not vary by gender"

Wang, Glob Health Res Policy 2020 (relative risks); Shor, Soc Sci Med 2012 and Demography 2012 (average hazard ratios); Moon, PLOS ONE 2011 (relative risks); Manzoli, Soc Sci Med 2007 (married vs non-married). 1.22 = 22% higher risk of death than married people of the same sex. All observational.

Part three · Quality

It's Not Just Married, It's How Married

Evidence: Moderate — small but consistent effects

Marital status is a crude label that puts a supportive partnership and a hostile one in the same box. A 2014 meta-analysis in Psychological Bulletin by Theodore Robles and colleagues looked at quality instead: 126 studies over 50 years, with more than 72,000 people (Robles, Psychol Bull 2014).

"Greater marital quality was related to better health," including a lower risk of death. The effects were small, "similar in magnitude to previously found associations between health behaviors (e.g., diet) and health outcomes." On sex, the picture was mixed: studies with a higher share of women showed larger effects, but studies that directly tested for a difference between women and men found little evidence of one.

This research can't say whether an unhappy marriage is better or worse for lifespan than being single. It does suggest the average "marriage benefit" spans very different relationships.

Part four · Children

Mothers, Childless Women and Family Size

Evidence: Consistent association — causes unclear

The best-known parenthood study is Swedish. Karin Modig and colleagues used national registers to follow 704,481 men and 725,290 women born between 1911 and 1925, all living in Sweden at 60 (Modig, J Epidemiol Community Health 2017).

At 60, women with at least one child could expect to live another 24.6 years, against 23.1 for childless women: about 1.5 years more. For men the figures were 20.2 and 18.4 years, about two years more. The difference in yearly risk of death grew with age: at 80 it was 0.71 percentage points for women and 0.90 for men, after accounting for education and marital status. The link held after accounting for whether people had a partner (it was somewhat stronger in the unmarried, at least among men) and didn't depend on the child's sex (full text).

The authors suggest support from adult children may explain part of it, but write that "selective elements and alternative explanations" can't be ruled out. Healthier people may be more likely to have children in the first place, and children living abroad weren't counted.

An older woman with white hair and a younger woman hugging and laughing outdoors
Support may be part of the link

Does the number of children matter?

The link isn't simply "more children, longer life".

What about having a child later?

A 2014 analysis in Menopause drew on the Long Life Family Study, which recruits families with unusually long-lived members, and compared 462 women who did and didn't live exceptionally long. Those whose last child came after 33 had twice the odds of living to 95 or older as women whose last child was born by 29. The study's corresponding author, Thomas Perls, stressed that "this does not mean women should wait to have children at older ages": a later birth may be a sign of slower ageing, not a cause of longer life (Boston University School of Public Health).

Figure 3 · The children evidence

What studies of parenthood and lifespan actually found

StudyWhoFindingMain caveat
Modig, Sweden, 2017725,290 women and 704,481 men born 1911–1925Life expectancy at 60: mothers 24.6 years, childless women 23.1 men: 20.2 vs 18.4Selection not ruled out
Zeng, meta-analysis, 201618 articles, 2.8 million peopleJ-shaped: lowest risk at 3–4 births; childless 19% higher risk than parentsWomen and men pooled
Barclay, Sweden, 2016Men and women born 1932–1960, siblings comparedU-shaped: highest mortality in the childless and those with 5+ childrenCause still uncertain
Long Life Family Study, 2014462 womenLast child after 33: twice the odds of reaching 95+, vs last child by 29A marker of ageing, not advice

Modig, J Epidemiol Community Health 2017; Zeng, Scientific Reports 2016; Barclay, Social Science & Medicine 2016; Long Life Family Study, Menopause 2014. All observational.

Part five · The viral claim

"Single, Childless Women Are Happiest": What Happened

Evidence: Claim partly corrected

In May 2019, behavioural scientist Paul Dolan of the London School of Economics spoke at the Hay Festival about his book Happy Ever After. As reported by The Guardian, he said: "The healthiest and happiest population subgroup are women who never married or had children." He said married people were happier "but only when their spouse is in the room", and that a married woman "dies sooner than if she never married" (The Guardian, via inkl).

The "spouse in the room" point didn't survive scrutiny. The economist Gray Kimbrough pointed out that in the American Time Use Survey, the category "spouse absent" refers to whether a spouse lives in the household, not whether they were in the room during the interview (Catholic News Agency). Dolan said he thought Kimbrough was right, that "we have misinterpreted the variable", and that he had contacted The Guardian and his editor so the book could be corrected. He kept his broader view that marriage is generally better for men than for women. The Guardian removed the passage about the spouse's presence from its report (Washington Free Beacon).

The claimSingle, childless women are the healthiest group; married women die sooner.
What the mortality studies showNever-married women had a higher risk of death than married women, not a lower one (46% higher in a 2020 meta-analysis). The gap is smaller than for men, the part of the claim that holds up.

The fair reading: the mortality gap linked to being unmarried is larger for men than for women, but the large studies don't support the idea that marriage shortens women's lives.

Part six · Why

Why the Link Exists, and Why It's Not the Whole Story

Evidence: Mechanisms plausible — not proven

Wang and colleagues discuss several explanations, which can coexist:

A 2010 meta-analysis in PLOS Medicine by Julianne Holt-Lunstad and colleagues pooled 148 studies with 308,849 people, followed for 7.5 years on average. People with stronger social relationships had a "50% increased likelihood of survival" (odds ratio 1.50), consistent across age and sex. Studies measuring only marital status were excluded; complex measures of social integration showed the strongest link (odds ratio 1.91). The authors called the influence of social relationships "comparable with well-established risk factors for mortality" (Holt-Lunstad, PLOS Med 2010).

A spouse and children are one route to that kind of connection; friends, siblings, neighbours and community are others. We covered the opposite in our write-up of a 277,489-person study of loneliness and healthy years.

Part seven · What to do

What This Means for You

Frequently Asked Questions

Do married women live longer than single women?
On average, a little. A 2020 meta-analysis of about 7.9 million people found unmarried women had a 22% higher risk of death than married women, against 46% for unmarried men. The studies are observational, so they can't show marriage is the cause.
Do women with children live longer?
In a Swedish registry study of about 1.4 million people born 1911 to 1925, mothers aged 60 could expect 24.6 more years of life and childless women 23.1. The authors could not rule out selection and other explanations.
Is it true that single, childless women are the happiest and healthiest?
The 2019 headline came from a talk by behavioural scientist Paul Dolan. Part of it rested on a misread survey variable, which Dolan acknowledged. Large mortality studies don't support the idea that married women die sooner.
Does widowhood shorten a woman's life?
The link is weaker in women than in men. One meta-analysis found widowed women had a 15% higher risk of death than married women, against 27% for widowed men. Another found the risk was highest in the first six months after bereavement, and found no statistically significant overall effect in women.
Does the quality of a marriage matter for health?
Yes. A meta-analysis of 126 studies with more than 72,000 people linked greater marital quality to better health and a lower risk of death, though the effects were small.
The Bottom Line

A modest average gap, not a life plan.

On average, married women and mothers live slightly longer than single and childless women. The gap is smaller for women than for men in most large analyses, and it's tangled up with who marries and has children in the first place.

The more useful finding cuts across every status: the quality of your relationships and how connected you are are linked to how long you live. You can build that at any age, married or not, with children or without. For questions about your own health risks, talk to your doctor.

Sources

  1. Wang Y, Jiao Y, Nie J, O'Neil A, Huang W, Zhang L, Han J, Liu H, Zhu Y, Yu C, Woodward M. Sex differences in the association between marital status and the risk of cardiovascular, cancer, and all-cause mortality: a systematic review and meta-analysis of 7,881,040 individuals. Global Health Research and Policy 2020;5:4 (doi:10.1186/s41256-020-00133-8). Abstract via DOAJ.
  2. Roelfs DJ, Shor E, Kalish R, Yogev T. The rising relative risk of mortality for singles: meta-analysis and meta-regression. American Journal of Epidemiology 2011;174(4):379–389 (doi:10.1093/aje/kwr111).
  3. Manzoli L, Villari P, Pirone GM, Boccia A. Marital status and mortality in the elderly: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Social Science & Medicine 2007;64(1):77–94.
  4. Shor E, Roelfs DJ, Bugyi P, Schwartz JE. Meta-analysis of marital dissolution and mortality: reevaluating the intersection of gender and age. Social Science & Medicine 2012;75(1):46–59.
  5. Shor E, Roelfs DJ, Curreli M, Clemow L, Burg MM, Schwartz JE. Widowhood and mortality: a meta-analysis and meta-regression. Demography 2012;49(2):575–606 (doi:10.1007/s13524-012-0096-x).
  6. Moon JR, Kondo N, Glymour MM, Subramanian SV. Widowhood and mortality: a meta-analysis. PLOS ONE 2011;6(8):e23465 (doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0023465).
  7. Robles TF, Slatcher RB, Trombello JM, McGinn MM. Marital quality and health: a meta-analytic review. Psychological Bulletin 2014;140(1):140–187 (doi:10.1037/a0031859).
  8. Modig K, Talbäck M, Torssander J, Ahlbom A. Payback time? Influence of having children on mortality in old age. Journal of Epidemiology & Community Health 2017;71:424–430 (doi:10.1136/jech-2016-207857).
  9. Zeng Y, Ni Z, Liu S, et al. Parity and all-cause mortality in women and men: a dose-response meta-analysis of cohort studies. Scientific Reports 2016;6:19351 (doi:10.1038/srep19351).
  10. Barclay K, Keenan K, Grundy E, Kolk M, Myrskylä M. Reproductive history and post-reproductive mortality: a sibling comparison analysis using Swedish register data. Social Science & Medicine 2016;155:82–92 (doi:10.1016/j.socscimed.2016.02.043).
  11. Boston University School of Public Health. Reproduction later in life is a marker for longevity in women. 25 June 2014 (on a Long Life Family Study analysis in Menopause).
  12. Extended maternal age at birth of last child and women's longevity in the Long Life Family Study. Menopause, published online 25 June 2014 (print edition January 2015); details via EurekAlert.
  13. Holt-Lunstad J, Smith TB, Layton JB. Social relationships and mortality risk: a meta-analytic review. PLOS Medicine 2010;7(7):e1000316 (doi:10.1371/journal.pmed.1000316).
  14. Cain S. Women are happier without children or a spouse, says happiness expert. The Guardian, 25 May 2019 (as syndicated by inkl).
  15. Catholic News Agency. Are single women actually happier? Study misinterprets data, researchers say. 29 May 2019 (republished by Catholic World Report).
  16. Lehman CF. No, marriage doesn't make you 'f---ing miserable'. Washington Free Beacon, 29 May 2019, updated 31 May 2019.